| Platinum | Mr. Sombrero #2 |
| Gold | Jimmy Changas |
| Silver | Esteban's Cafe y Cantina |
| Bronze | Senor Sombreros |
| Top Pick | Barcenas Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | El Dorado Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Las Haciendas Mexican Bar & Grill |
| Top Pick | Luna's Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | South Shore Grille |
| Top Pick | Taqueria Chalupas |