| Platinum | Gio's Flying Pizza and Pasta |
| Gold | Village Pizza & Seafood |
| Silver | Pomodoro's Cucina Italiana |
| Bronze | Bada Bing Pizza |
| Top Pick | Angelo's Pizza and Pasta |
| Top Pick | Dan's Pizza Co. |
| Top Pick | Grimaldi's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Hyde Park Kitchen + Bar |
| Top Pick | Pizza Hut |
| Top Pick | Roma Pizza |